Local businesses – Your Customer’s Decision Journey

For large brands, a customer’s decision journey (from McKinsey Quarterly) looks like this:

Tradition brands - Customer Decision Journey

Tradition brands - Customer Decision Journey

To get in the initial consideration set, businesses have to spend money on TV/Newpaper/Radio advertising, coupons or search engine campaigns. Most of these options do not work for local businesses because:

  1. Local businesses get customers from a 2-mile radius.
  2. Groupon and other coupons etc. might drive customers from a little farther but these customers will typically not come back (expand the 2 mile radius to 5 miles).
  3. Traditional TV/Radio advertising is expensive to produce, hard to target and impossible to measure. Given the huge upfront investment and wasteful targeting, its not really an option for most business.
  4. Local newspapers used to work but with the advent of the internet their circulation and effectiveness is declining.
  5. Search engine marketing is interesting but most customers do not discover restaurants via search engines. (When was the last time you searched for and clicked on an ad for a local restaurant)? In addition, because of the time and expertise it takes to get your campaigns right, its not a viable option for most customers.
  6. Search engine optimization is an interesting approach that can work but customers need a content strategy and SEO expertise to leverage this approach. Search engine optimization based on fresh content from user reviews is how Yelp! gets so much traffic and influence.
  7. Facebook campaigns is another approach that is available to businesses but again it takes time and effort. In addition nobody really knows how to measure the ROI from these expensive campaigns.

The only thing that has worked for local businesses has been word-of-mouth marketing. Good restaurant owners know the value of spending table-time with the customers as it drives repeat and referral traffic. For local businesses the customer decision journey looks like the following:

Restaurants: Loyal customers drive referrals

Restaurants: Loyal customers drive referrals

Since referrals are the main way to acquire customers for local businesses, encouraging and engaging loyal customers is more important than ever. Punchh’s social loyalty program enables the EEARS™ (engage, empower, amplify, refer and sustain) process for businesses to:

  1. Engage: Businesses can engage their customers with a mobile-phone based loyalty program. Forget about complex points schemes that most users have no idea about, Punchh’s simple punchh card approach makes sure that customers always know the score and are fully engaged.
  2. Empower: Loyal customers to local businesses are interested in having a conversation. These customers think of a local restaurant as an important part of their life. This means that with Punchh, when you empower customers to review your locations and ask for feedback, you hear a lot of voices. Punchh enables users to post these reviews directly on their facebook walls and allows businesses to directly address any service issues with customers before they become bigger problems.
  3. Amplify: Loyal customer reviews provide a business with an important and valuable content source. Businesses can use this content to repost it to their facebook wall or twitter feed or even on their website to drive engagement in the community. After all, there is no better way to market your business than to show real customer testimonials. In addition, by using customer reviews and posting them on their website, businesses can drive organic search ranking for great SEO rankings.
  4. Refer: Your loyal customers already like your business. With Punchh businesses can now reward these customers who drive referrals with extra punchhs or free food. This finally provides local businesses a way to incentivize real referrals in a natural way. In addition, by using Punchh businesses can enable social campaigns like gifting, invitations, group rewards and charity campaigns to really drive new and repeat business, all in a fully measurable fashion.
  5. Sustain: Once customers are signed up with Punchh, businesses can re-engage these customers by sending them context specific email campaigns like “Hey haven’t seen you for 2 months, come back and earn an extra punchh” etc. Businesses can also bring customers back with automatic location sensitive alerts such as “Hey, Looks like you are in the neighborhood, you already have 3 punchhs… Come in and get more punchhs towards your free food”. For special occasions and during slow times, businesses can deliver coupons to their loyal customers all either automatically or from a easy to use web interface. All these approaches ensure that local businesses are sustaining their engagement with their customers.

Punchh Social marketing drives ROI

Punchh’s EEARS™ process encapsulates the best marketing processes for your local business and requires no special training as it works on auto-pilot. Try out our service to see how we deliver great results by mapping your marketing to your customer decision cycle realities.

Posted in Loyalty Programs, punchh | Leave a comment

Punchh Webinar

Webinar we recently did with Running Restaurant (Thanks Jaime)

http://www.attendthisevent.com/SlideReplay.asp?eventID=22822851&IAID=4670028

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Put more butts in seats by engaging your customers

The restaurant business has always been about customer relationships. Existing customers are the engines that drive your business because happy customers come back and tell their friends about their great experiences. In fact, typically 70% of the customers that walk into a restaurant do so based on a friends recommendation. Given the incredible value of existing customers, restaurants need to own these customers not only to unlock their value in the form of referrals, repeat visits and positive reviews but also because just relying on other networks like Groupon, Yelp and Foursquare etc. can have disastrous consequences.

Renting is not owning

Traditional approaches to local marketing have all been about participating in somebody else’s network. Yelp promotions enable you to present your restaurant to people reading reviews in your area and Foursquare specials enable you to promote your service to Foursquare users. Groupon deals allow a restaurant to provide a great deal to their network of users.

While all these networks can help you “rent” their members in order to recruit new customers they all require a great deal of expertise and know-how to get the best results. In addition these networks do nothing to promote repeat/referral business from these customer and in fact can actually hurt the chances of having repeat visits by rewarding customers for a behavior that can drive them to a competitor. E.g. with Groupon some of customers buying your coupons could be already loyal customers so a business is not only discounting their product for no return but also reducing the value of your experience in eyes of your most valuable customers. Also with Groupon a business might also be signing up customers that are unlikely to return (might be far away from your location etc.) as they were interested just because of the massive discount. A business really needs to have a process and a plan in place to drive and measure repeat & and referral customers before undertaking any of these network based approaches in order to avoid these issues.

Keys to unlocking the value of your customers

Following are the keys to unlocking the value of your customers
• Know your loyal customers
• Engage and reward them when they come back
• Give them tools to spread the word-of-mouth about the restaurant
• Reward them when their friends come and visit

Over the years restaurants have been trying to find a way to achieve these results and best restaurateurs are still able to implement these steps by relying on personal relationships. But in the age of facebook and extreme customer mobility, personal relationships are often not sufficient.

Some restaurants create forms for customers to fill out and use these forms to create a customer database (a laborious and error prone process). Other customers ask their patrons to follow them on Facebook (once a customer leaves the premises, its hard to have them do anything). Still others institute paper punch cards (fraud prone and no way to collect customer information) or swipe card based loyalty program (expensive, poor registration rates and low ROI). All these approaches are either ineffective or require a herculean effort from the already-busy owners.

How to effectively engage your customers and put more butts in seats with Punchh

Punchh provides a turn-key solution that puts simple punch cards on customers phone. By relying on your customer’s mobile devices, Punchh engages restaurant customers on premise, at a time they are most open to engaging with the restaurant. By digitizing the cards and loyalty interaction, Punchh enables customers to create and manage their profiles with a restaurant so your customer information base is always correct and up-to-date. These profiles can then be combined with the context of when a customer came in and what they ordered to drive campaigns that bring back customers and strengthen engagement.

In addition, Punchh connects a mobile phone based punch card with Facebook. By providing restaurant customers the tools to spread the word-of-mouth, and rewarding them when their friends actually show up, Punchh provides restaurants a way to drive and measure the word-of-mouth and to put more butts in seats.

Punchh users typically create more reviews for a restaurant in a month than Yelp reviews ever. To address any negative comments, Punchh provides a dashboard for you to respond and resolve issues. In addition, you can repost the best comments to their own Facebook fan page or Twitter accounts. This allows restaurants to not only address all negative reviews to nip potential issues in the bud but also enables them to engage their community by spreading positive reviews.

Since Punchh relies on customers phones, it requires no hardware or software installs and businesses can be up and running in days.

Smart businesses ensure that they own their most valuable assets. Its time to start owning your customers and Punchh can help.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Most Facebook Fans Not Local – WSJ

Interesting article over at the WSJ about how only 15% of the average local business’s fans are in the city where the business is located. What does this mean? As the article suggests, local businesses have to try harder to target local fans. At Punchh, we solve this problem by giving customers who have walked in to your business the tools to talk about you on Facebook/Twitter and other social media channels. It turns out that by a vast majority, most of the customers who engage with a business through Punchh *are* local customers. Giving these customers the ability to interact with your brand through social media channels is the right way to engage with your clients if you run a local business.

*Getty Images

In the end, Facebook and Twitter are channels for marketing – properly targeted, they are phenomenally useful in engaging with your customers. You wouldn’t run a radio spot without understanding your target demographic, would you? The same applies for social media marketing – and using the right tools to help you with that targeting is the key to an effective marketing campaign (whether with Facebook/Twitter or with traditional media campaigns).

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Interview with PMQ magazine

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Punchh Card Designer

We’ve been meaning to write about how to design a custom card on Punchh for a while now. When you sign up at punchh.com, as part of the sign-in process, we give you the opportunity to design a custom card (that is automatically displayed on the Punchh Iphone and Android apps). This custom card can have your branding and your logos and your specific offer.

You can also always change your design/look and feel of your card through our Punchh dashboard after you sign-up. Here’s a short video describing how to use it:

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Punchh in 60 seconds – From the NRA Show

Thanks Jaime!!

Jitendra Gupta

BTW, guys, great job with the collateral!!! Great to work with a team that knows what it’s doing.

See Jaime’s coverage of NRA here.

From Jaime blog post:

The first thing that always hits me when I walk into a big restaurant show like the NRA is how many choices restaurant operators have to make.

There are just countless areas to consider – from marketing and technology to sanitation and packaging to uniforms, equipment and more – oh yeah, and food of course!

What a juggle…

What a challenge…

Fun, but daunting at the same time…

Does any other type of business have so many moving parts?

You have to take your hat off to restaurant folks for even attempting to pull off such a coordinated effort!

Jaime, thanks for articulating these sentiments…Couldn’t have done it better myself.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Case Study: Punchh @ Pasta Pomodoro (Stores magazine)

Case study of usage of Punchh at Pasta Pomodoro (Thanks Matt!!), with fantastic information on the market context for our service. See it here

Punchh and Pasta Pomodoro make sweet music together

Punchh Screen shots

Punchh at Pasta Pomodoro

Check it out here

Posted in Loyalty Programs, Uncategorized | Leave a comment

300K new restaurants

We have just added 300,000 new locations to our location database! This means that you no longer have an excuse to not Punchh at your favorite spots. Check it out and keep adding the locations that we don’t already have and keep Punchhing:

Punchh has 300K more restaurarants

This effort required a lot of data scrubbing and cleanup etc.  But despite our best efforts, you might see some locations mis-categorized. Please do give us a holler at “support at punchh dot com” and we will take care of it.

Also, all the locations have new, good looking default cards:

Finally, remember -  “Punchh means free lunch” :-)

Posted in Loyalty Programs, punchh, Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Social Media definition

Check out this great piece by Judy Shapiro in AdAge about her struggles with the term ‘social media’. She says it better than I can, so I’ll just quote her:

The best construct I can come up with is to define the marketing world as two camps: the “one-to-many” camp representing the marketing model of the last 25 years (e.g. one brand markets to many people), and the “many-to-many” camp, where we reframe social media as a lead performer (but not the solo performer) in a bigger, newly emerging community-centered marketing system.

It’s not an either/or situation but a maturing of thinking that allows us as marketers to work both systems for optimal effect. At a 30,000-foot level, here’s how they differ:

We believe that most restaurants and indeed local businesses, have been doing “many-to-many” marketing for years. In fact, if you talk to most restaurant owners, they will tell you that the majority of their customers come from other people spreading the word about their business (referrals, bring along etc.). Judy has this table to drive home the differences:

Social Media Marketing is different than traditional one-to-many marketing

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment